The operational efficiency measurement of agro-food supply chains: the single “farmer-supermarket direct purchase” vs. dual channel

PU Xujin1,2 JIN Delong1

(1.Business School, Jiangnan University, Wuxi, China 214122)
(2.Synergetic Innovation Center of Food Safety and Nutrition, Wuxi, China 214122)

【Abstract】An agricultural cooperative is an association of farmers who voluntarily cooperate to pool their production for sales. In China, the agricultural cooperatives are increasingly encouraged to sell their fresh agricultural products to supermarkets, and supermarkets hold a significant market share in agricultural product distribution from farms to final consumers. However, some of agricultural cooperatives still prefer to sell a part (or all) of their production directly to end consumers. In practice, many farmers combine direct selling and marketing through cooperatives. They sell part of their production to the cooperatives and the rest is sold directly to consumers. The combination of direct selling with supermarkets gives rise to a particular market structure for the agricultural cooperatives. The purpose of this paper is to study whether it is necessary for the cooperatives to establish community outlet stores to sell fresh agricultural products to consumers directly. A model in which an agricultural cooperative is owned by many farmers who produce a homogeneous good is built. It is assumed that the supermarkets and the direct selling market are separated. The supermarkets are oligopolistic, but the price of fresh agro-food in the direct selling market is controlled by the government. The agricultural cooperative decides on the production quantity and how to share this production the supermarkets and the direct selling market. A Nash bargaining model is developed to analyze the game process between the cooperative and the supermarket. The equilibrium results are derived and the resulting profit sensitivity with respect to some factors is analyzed. Our analysis stresses three important results. First, it is find that the cooperative will benefit from the opening of the community outlet store; however, the profit of supermarket will decrease. Second, as the bargaining power of the cooperative decreases, the degree of improvement for the cooperative’s profit will become more significant. Finally, the operational efficiency of the whole supply chain can be improved significantly in the dual channel when the production capability of the cooperative is greater than a threshold. Simultaneously, a numerical simulation is proposed to prove the results. The contribution of this paper is twofold. First, it is an attempt to build a theoretical framework for a agricultural cooperative to decide on how to share production between the supermarkets and the direct selling market. Second, the results of this paper can provide implications for the government in China to develop more efficient agricultural supply chains.

【Keywords】 agro-food supply chain; “farmer-supermarket direct purchase”; community outlet stores; dual channel; asymmetric Nash bargaining;


【Funds】 National Natural Science Foundation of China (71371086) National Social Science Fund of China (14ZDA069) National Social Science Fund of China (16BJY185)

Download this article

(Translated by YUAN Zhen)


    [1] Hu Dinghuan, Reardon T, Rozelle S, et al. The emergence of supermarkets with Chinese characteristics: Challenges and opportunities for China’s agricultural development. Development Policy Review, 2004, 22 (5): 557–586.

    [2] Traill W B. The rapid rise of supermarkets. Development Policy Review, 2006, 24 (2): 163–174.

    [3] Wang Honglin, Dong Xiaonia, Rozelle S, et al. Producing and procuring horticultural crops with Chinese characteristics: the case of Northern China. World Development. 2009, 37 (11): 1791–1801.

    [4] Michelson H, Reardon T, Perez F. Small farmers and big retail: Trade–offs of supplying supermarkets in Nicaragua. World Development, 2012, 40 (2): 342–354.



    [7] Chiang W K, Chhajed D, Hess J D. Direct marketing, indirect profits: A strategic analysis of dual-channel supply chain design. Management Science, 2003, 49 (1): 1–20.

    [8] Cai G. Channel selection and coordination in dual-channel supply chains. Journal of Retailing, 2010, 86 (1): 22–36.

    [9] Lu H, Chen Yingju. Strategic motive for introducing internet channels in a supply chain. Production and Operations Management, 2014, 23 (1): 36–47.

    [10] Albert H, Long Xiaoyang, Javad N. Quality in supply chain encroachment. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2015, 18 (2): 280–298.

    [11] Abhishek V, Jerath K, Zhang Z J. Agency selling or reselling? Channel structures in electronic retailing. Management Science, 2016, 8 (62): 2259–2280.

    [12] Cai Xiaoqiang, Chen Jian, Xiao Yongbo, et al. Fresh product supply chain management with logistics outsourcing. Omega, 2013, 41 (4): 752–765.

    [13] Li, L. & Fan, T. Chinese Journal of Management Science (中国管理科学), 23 (12): 113–123 (2015).

    [14] Ling, L., Guo, X. Hu, Z. et al. Chinese Journal of Management Science (中国管理科学), 21 (2): 50–57 (2013).

    [15] Xiong, F., Peng, J. Jin, P. et al. Chinese Journal of Management Science (中国管理科学), 23 (8): 102–111 (2015).

    [16] Yang, Y., Fan, T. & Zhang, L. Chinese Journal of Management Science (中国管理科学), 24 (9): 147–155 (2016).

    [17] Niu Baozhuang, Jin Delong, Pu Xujin. Coordination of channel members’ efforts and utilities in contract farming operations. European Journal of Operational Research, 2016, 255: 869–883.

    [18] Jang W, Klein C M. Supply chain models for small agricultural enterprises. Annals of Operations Research, 2011, 190 (1): 359–374.

    [19] Agbo M, Rousseliere D, SalaniéJ. Agricultural marketing cooperatives with direct selling: A cooperative non cooperative game. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2015, 109:56–71.

    [20] Ling, L., Hu, Z. Guo, X. et al. Journal of Systems & Management (系统管理学报), 21 (3): 289–294 (2012).

    [21] Nash J F. The bargaining problem. Econometrica, 1950, 18 (2): 155–162.

This Article


CN: 11-2835/G3

Vol 25, No. 01, Pages 98-105

January 2017


Article Outline


  • 1 Introduction
  • 2 Problem description and basic assumption
  • 3 Model building and decision optimization
  • 4 Comparison of supply chain operation in different models
  • 5 Conclusion
  • References