Cultural reproduction or cultural mobility?: a study on the inequality of college students’ educational achievements in China
【Abstract】Using data from the Beijing College Students Panel Survey (BCSPS), this paper examined class differences in college students’ educational achievements in China. The results show that the elite families’ offspring are more likely to become student cadres and have better language ability. However, they attain lower academic scores. This is because the cultural reproduction mechanism is greatly weakened in the standardized system and students from the lower class are able to obtain good academic scores with their own efforts. Compared with academic achievement, standards for electing student cadres are more open and subjective, and social origin plays an important role. Furthermore, students from the elite class families benefit from their cultural capital much more than their counterparts from the lower class families. This result supports the cultural reproduction theory.
【Keywords】 cultural reproduction; cultural resistance; cultural mobility; educational achievement; inequality of educational opportunity;
. This paper is revised based on a chapter in the author’s doctoral thesis. Thanks to doctoral supervisor, professor Li lulu for his long-term and thoughtful guidance. Thanks to the anonymous reviewers for their valuable suggestions. This paper is the result of the “Education Stratified Research in Contemporary China” project (17XNF028) of the Scientific Research Fund of Renmin University of China (the special fund for basic scientific research of central universities). [^Back]
. ① Thanks to professors Feng Shizheng, Wang Weidong and Li Ding for their generosity in providing the research data. [^Back]
. ② For detailed information about the survey, please refer to the Report on Chinese College Students 2014 (Li, 2014). [^Back]
Bourdieu, P. La Noblesse d’État: Grandes écoles et esprit de corps. Yang, Y. (trans.) Beijing: The Commercial Press, (2004).
Bourdieu, P. & Passeron, J. 2002a, La Reproduction: Eléments pour une théorie du système d’enseignement. Xing, K. (trans.) Beijing: The Commercial Press, (2002a).
Bourdieu, P. & Passeron, J.C. 2002b, Les Héritiers. Xing, K. (trans.) Beijing: The Commercial Press, (2002b).
Blackledge, D. & Hunt, B. Sociological interpretations of education. Wang, B., Chen, F. & Hu, P. (trans.) Beijing: Chunqiu Press, (1989).
Hao, D. Social Sciences in China (中国社会科学), (6) (2007).
Hong, Y. & Zhao, Y. Sociological Studies (社会学研究), (4) (2014).
Hu, A. Journal of Social Sciences (社会科学), (1) (2017).
Karabel, J. The Chosen: The Hidden History of Admission and Exclusion at Harvard, Yale, and Princeton. Xie, A. & Zhou, S. (trans.) Beijing: China Renmin University Press, (2014).
Lai, D., Meng, D. & Su, L. Peking University Education Review (北京大学教育评论), (1) (2012).
Li, C. Sociological Studies (社会学研究), (3) (2010).
Li, C. Sociological Studies (社会学研究), (2) (2014).
Li, F., Hou, L. & Wen, D. Society (社会), (1) (2006).
Li, H., Meng, L. Shi, X. et al. China Economic Quarterly (经济学 (季刊)), (3) (2012).
Li, L. Report on Chinese College Students 2014 (中国大学生成长报告 (2014)). Beijing: China Renmin University Press, (2014).
Li, Y. Social Sciences in China (中国社会科学), (4) (2006).
Li, Z. Society (社会), (3) (2016).
Li, Z. & Qiu, Z. Sociological Studies (社会学研究), (4) (2016).
Liu, J. Society (社会), (3) (2006).
Sun, Y. Youth Studies (青年研究), (2) (2010).
Tang, J. Sociological Studies (社会学研究), (3) (2015).
Wang, R., in Zhang, R. (ed.), Sociology of Education: Scholars and Their Thoughts (教育社会学: 人物与思想). Shanghai: East China Normal University Press, (2009).
Willis, P. Learning to Labor: How Working Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs. Mi, S. & Ling, M. (trans.) Nanjing: Yilin Press, (2013).
Wu, X. Society (社会), (5) (2009).
Wu, X. Society (社会), (3) (2016).
Wu, Y. Sociological Studies (社会学研究), (4) (2013).
Xiong, C. & Liu, H. Peking University Education Review (北京大学教育评论), (4) (2014).
Xu, D. Society (社会), (4) (2017).
Xu, J., Liu, T. & Li, P. Economic Science (经济科学), (1) (2014).
Ye, X. & Ding, Y. Society (社会), (3) (2015).
Yue, C. & Zhang, K. Educational Research (教育研究), (11) (2014).
Zhang, S. & Cheng, C. Youth Studies (青年研究), (2) (2009).
Zhou, X. Society (社会), (5) (2011).
Zhu, X., Shi, J. & Dong, Z. Journal of Higher Education (高等教育研究), (4) (2013).
Aschaffenburg, Karen & Ineke Maas 1997, “Cultural and Educational Careers: The Dynamics of Social Reproduction.” American Sociological Review 62(4).
Blaskó, Zsuzsa 2003, “Cultural Reproduction or Cultural Mobility?” Review of Sociology 9(1).
Boudon, Raymond 1974, “Education, Opportunity, and Social Inequality.” In Changing Prospects in Western Society. New York: Wiley.
Bourdieu, Pierre 1986, “The Forms of Capital.” In J. Richardson (ed.),Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. Westport, CT, Greenwood.
Breen, Richard & Jan O. Jonsson 2005 “Inequality of Opportunity in Comparative Perspective: Recent Research on Educational Attainment and Social Mobility.” Annual Review of Sociology 31.
Breen, Richard, Ruud Luijkx, Walter Muller & Reinhard Pollak 2009, “Nonpersistent Inequality in Educational Attainment: Evidence from Eight European Countries.” American Journal of Sociology 114(5).
Byun, Soo-yong, Evan Schofer & Kyung-keun Kim 2012 “Revisiting the Role of Cultural Capital in East Asian Educational Systems: The Case of South Korea.” Sociology of Education 85(3).
De Graaf, Nan Dirk, Paul M. De Graaf & Gerbert Kraay kamp 2000, “Parental Cultural Capital and Educational Attainment in the Netherlands: A Refinement of the Cultural Capital Perspective.” Sociology of Education 73(2).
DiMaggio, Paul 1982 “Cultural Capital and School Success: The Impact of Status Culture Participation on the Grades of US High School Students.” American Sociological Review 47(2).
DiMaggio, Paul & John Mohr 1985, “Cultural Capital, Educational Attainment, and Marital Selection.” American Journal of Sociology 90(6).
Dumais, Susan A. 2002 “Cultural Capital, Gender, and School Success: The Role of Habitus.” Sociology of Education 75(1).
Farkas, George 2003, “Cognitive Skills and Noncognitive Traits and Behaviors in Stratification Processes.” Annual Review of Sociology 29.
Giroux, Henry A. 1983, “Theories of Reproduction and Resistance in the New Sociology of Education: A Critical Analysis.” Harvard Educational Review 53(3).
Goldrick-Rab, Sara & Fabian T. Pfeffer 2009, “Beyond Access: Explaining Socioeconomic Differences in College Transfer.” Sociology of Education 82(2).
Horn, Daniel 2009, Age of Selection Counts: A Cross-Country Analysis of Educational Institutions.” Education Research and Evaluation 15(4).
Jæger, Mads Meier 2011, “Does Cultural Capital Really Affect Academic Achievement? New Evidence from Combined Sibling and Panel Data.” Sociology of Education 84(4).
Katsillis, John & Richard Rubinson 1990 “Cultural Capital, Student Achievement, and Educational Reproduction: The Case of Greece.” American Sociological Review 55(2).
Lamont, Michele & Annette Lareau 1988, “Cultural Capital: Allusions, Gaps and Glissandos in Recent Theoretical Developments.” Sociological Theory 6(2).
Lareau, Annette 2015, “Cultural Knowledge and Social Inequality.” American Sociological Review 80(1).
Lareau, Annette & Elliot B. Weininger 2003, “Cultural Capital in Educational Research: A Critical Assessment.” Theory and Society 32.
Lehmann, Wolfgang 2012 “Extra-Credential Experiences and Social Closure: Working-Class Students at University.” British Educational Research Journal 38(2).
Lucas, Samuel R. 2001, “Effectively Maintained Inequality: Education Transitions, Track Mobility, and Social Background Effects.” The American Journal of Sociology 106(6).
Mullen, Ann L., Kimberly A. Goyette & Joseph A. Soares 2000 “Leveling the Playing Field? Students’ Educational Attainment and States’ Performance Testing.” Sociology of Education 73(3).
Park, Hyunjoon 2008, “The Varied Educational Effects of Parent-Child Communication: A Comparative Study of Fourteen Countries.” Comparative Education Review 52(2).
Pfeffer, Fabian T. 2008, “Persistent Inequality in Educational Attainment and its Institutional Context.” European Sociological Review 24(5).
Raftery, Adrian E. & Michael Hout 1993 “Maximally Maintained Inequality: Expansion, Reform, and Opportunity in Irish Education, 1921–75.” Sociology of Education 66(1).
Roksa, Josipa & Daniel Potter 2011, “Parenting and Academic Achievement Intergenerational Transmission of Educational Advantage.” Sociology of Education 84(4).
Stevenson, David L. & David P. Baker 1991, “State Control of the Curriculum and Classroom Instruction.” Sociology of Education 64(I).
Stuber, Jenny M. 2009, “Class, Culture, and Participation in the Collegiate Extra-Curriculum.” Sociological Forum 24(4).
Sullivan, Alice 2001, “Cultural Capital and Educational Attainment.” Sociology 35(4).
Van de Werfhorst, Herman G. & Mijs, J. B. Jonathan 2010 “Achievement Inequality and the Institutional Structure of Educational Systems: A Comparative Perspective.” Annual Review of Sociology 36.
Xu, Jun & Gillian Hampden-Thompson 2011, “Cultural Reproduction, Cultural Mobility, Cultural Resources, or Trivial Effect? A Comparative Approach to Cultural Capital and Educational Performance.” Comparative Education Review 56(1).