Pressure to excel and corporate misconduct: data analysis based on Chinese listed firms

HE Xiaogang1,2 DENG Hao1 WU Shiyu1 LIANG Peng1

(1.School of International Business Administration, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics)
(2.Shanghai University of Finance and Economics Zhejiang College)

【Abstract】Executive managers have incentives to conduct upward comparison. And some firms make pursuing becoming “No. 1” as their future business goal in mission statements. Such aspiration-oriented goal setting brings along institutionalized pressure to excel, which will impose significant effect upon corporate misconduct like illegal operations and rent-seeking activities. This essay includes institutionalized pressure to excel in misconduct decision-making model and empirically research on data of Chinese listed firm from 2007 to 2012. Research results of this essay show that the higher institutionalized pressure to excel firms face with, the more they are motivated to engage in misconduct such as illegal operations and rent-seeking. In addition, this research also finds that firms’ external competition environment imposes significant moderation effect upon institutionalized pressure to excel and corporate misconduct. The higher the industry competitiveness is, the more likelihood will be increased that firms with pressure to excel would engage in misconduct. The cost of carry publicized by securities analysts on capital market adds to incentives for aspiration-oriented firms to take misconduct. This essay introduces the strategy to excel—firms pursuing the best performance or status—into decision-making model, which offers a new perspective in understanding risk taking behavior of firms in decision-making and enriches research achievement on corporate misconduct.

【Keywords】 strategy to excel; pressure to excel; misconduct; industry competitiveness; analysts’ assessment;

【DOI】

【Funds】 This research is sponsored by National Natural Science Foundation of China (71172140, 71372037) Shanghai Municipality Social Sciences Development Project (2011BGL007) and Follow-up Program of State Projects at Shanghai University of Finance and Economics (2012110294)

Download this article

    Footnote

    [1]. 1 In actual practice, screening of matching variables in this research is done in the way of stepwise regression and exclusion. Due to page limit, specific Logit regression process and results are not presented in the essay and they are available with the authors upon request. [^Back]

    [2]. 2 In addition, this research also adopts radium matching and kernel matching. The results are similar. [^Back]

    [3]. 3 Due to page limit, examination results are not presented in the essay and they are available with the authors upon request. [^Back]

    References

    (1) Chen, X., Chen, D. & Wan, H. Management World (管理世界), (11) (2009).

    (2) Chen, D., Chen, X. & Wan, Hu. Economic Research Journal (经济研究), (2) (2005).

    (3) Du, X., Chen, Y. & Du, Y. Journal of Financial Research (金融研究), (11) (2010).

    (4) Feng, X., Li, X. & Chen, G. Journal of Financial Research (金融研究), (3) (2011).

    (5) Feng, X. China Economic Quarterly (经济学(季刊)), (11) (2012).

    (6) Lai, M., Bao, Q. & Peng, S. et al. Economic Research Journal (经济研究), (8) (2005).

    (7) Li, X. & Chen, B. Economic Research Journal (经济研究), (10) (2013).

    (8) Tan, Y., Liao, J. & Li, J. Management World (管理世界), (12) (2011).

    (9) Tu, G. & Liu, F. Management World (管理世界), (11) (2010).

    (10) Wan, H. & Chen, X. China Economic Quarterly (经济学(季刊)), (1) (2010).

    (11) Wu, Y. China Economic Quarterly (经济学(季刊)), (3) (2008).

    (12) Zhang, X., Xu, J. & Xu, L. Economic Research Journal (经济研究), (3) (2015).

    (13) Zhuang, Z. Economic Research Journal (经济研究), (8) (2007).

    (14)Agnew,Robert,Nicole Leeper Piquero and Francis T. Cullen,2009,The Criminology of White-Collar Crime,New York: Springer.

    (15)Ansoff,H.I.,1979,Strategic Management,London: Macmillan.

    (16)Audia P. G. and Greve,H. R.,2006,“Less Likely to Fail?Low Performance,Firm Size,and Factory Expansion in the Shipbuilding Industry”,Management Science,Vol. 52,pp. 83-94.

    (17)Barney,Jay,1991,“Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage”,Journal of Management,Vol. 17(1),pp. 99-120.

    (18)Baucus,M.S.,1994,“Pressure,Opportunity and Predisposition: A Multivariate Model of Organization Illegality”,Journal of Management,Vol. 20,pp. 699-721.

    (19)Baucus,M. S. and Near,J.P.,1991,“Can Illegal Corporate Behavior Be Predicted? An Event History Analysis”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol. 34(1),pp. 9-36.

    (20)Baumgartner,F. R.,Grossman,E. and Brouard S.,2009,“Agenda-Setting Dynamics in France: Revisiting the‘Partisan Hypothesis’”,French Politics,Vol. 7(2),pp. 57-95.

    (21)Baumol,W.J.,1990,“Entrepreneurship: Productive,Unproductive,and Destructive”,Journal of Political Economy,Vol. 98,pp. 893-921.

    (22)Beneish,M. D.,1999,“Incentives and Penalties Related to Earnings Overstatements that Violate GAAP”,Accounting Review,Vol. 74(4),pp. 425-457.

    (23)Bertrand,M.,Bombardini,M. and Trebbi,F.,2011,“Is it Whom you Know or What you Know? An Empirical Assessment of the Lobbying Process”,Working Paper,University of Chicago.

    (24)Bhide A. V.,2000,The Origin and Evolution of New Business,Oxford University Press.

    (25)Bowman,E. H.,1980,“A Risk/Return Paradox for Strategic Management”,Sloan Management Review,Vol. 21(3),pp. 17-31.

    (26)Bowen,H. and De Clercq,D.,2008,“Institutional Context and the Allocation of Entrepreneurial Effort”,Journal of International Business Studies,Vol. 39,pp. 747-767.

    (27)Bromiley,P.,1991,“Testing a Causal Model of Corporate Risk Taking and Performance”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol. 34(1),pp.37-59.

    (28)Bureau,S. and Fendt,J.,2011,“Entrepreneurship in the Informal Economy: Why it Matters”,The International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation,Vol. 12(2),pp. 85-94.

    (29)Chen,W. R. and Miller,K.D.,2007,“Situational and Institutional Determinants of Firms' R&D Search Intensity”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol. 28(4),pp. 369-381.

    (30)Chrisman,J. J. and Patel,P. C.,2012,“Variations in R&D Investments of Family and Nonfamily Firms: Behavioral Agency and Myopic Loss Aversion Perspectives”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol. 55(4),976-997.

    (31)Clinard,Marshall,B. and Peter,C. Yeager,1980,Corporate Crime,New York and London: The Free Press.

    (32)Collis David J. and Montgomery Cynthia A.,1995,Competing on Resources: Strategy in the 1990s,Harvard Business.

    (33)Desai and Acs,2007,“Theory of Destructive Entrepreneurship”,Jena Economic Research Papers,Working Paper.

    (34)Desai,P. and Purohit,D.,1998,“Leasing and Selling: Optimal Marketing Strategies for a Durable Goods Firm”,Management Science,Vol. 44(11),pp. 19-34.

    (35)Driscoll,J. C. and Kraay,A. C.,1998,“Consistent Covariance Matrix Estimation with Spatially Dependent Panel Data”,Review of Economics and Statistics,Vol. 80(4),pp. 549-560.

    (36)Festinger and Leon,1954,“A Theory of Social Comparison Processes”,Human Relations,Vol. 7(2),pp. 117-140.

    (37)Fiegenbaum,A.,Hart,S. and Schendel,D.,1996,“Strategic Reference Point Theory”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol. 17(3),pp. 219-235.

    (38)Gentry,R. J.and Shen,W.,2013,“The Impacts of Performance Relative to Analyst Forecasts and Analyst Coverage on Firm R&D Intensity”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol. 34,pp. 121-130.

    (39)Gooding,Richard,Z.,Sanjay Goel and Robert M. Wiseman.,1996,“Fixed versus Variable Reference Points in the Risk-Return Relationship”,Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,Vol. 29(2),pp. 331-350.

    (40)Greve,H. R.,1998,“Managerial Cognition and the Mimetic Adoption of Market Positions:What you See is What you Do”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol. 19(10),pp. 967-988.

    (41)Greve,H.R.,2003c,Organizational Learning from Performance Feedback,Cambridge,UK: Cambridge University Press.

    (42)Greve,H. R.,Palmer D. and Pozner J.E.,2010,“Organizations Gone Wild: The Causes,Processes and Consequences of Organizational Misconduct”,Academic Management Annals,Vol. 4(1),pp. 53-107.

    (43)Guo,Y.,2008,“Corruption in Transitional China: An Empirical Analysis”,The China Quarterly,Vol. 194,pp. 349-364.

    (44)Haushalter,D.,Klasa,S.,and Maxwell,W.F.,2007,“The Influence of Product Market Dynamics on a Firm's Cash Holdings and Hedging Behavior”,Journal of Financial Economics,Vol. 84(3),pp. 797-825.

    (45)Heath,C.,Huddart,S. and Lang,M.,1999,“Psychological Factors and Stock Option Exercise”,The Quarterly Journal of Economics,pp. 601-627.

    (46)Jensen,M. C. and Meckling,W.H.,1976,“Theory of Firm: Managerial Behavior,Agency Costs and Ownership Structure”,The Journal of Finance,Vol. 3(4),pp. 305-360.

    (47)Kahneman,D. and Tversky,A.,1979,“Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk”,Journal of the Econometric Society,Vol. 4,pp. 263-291.

    (48)Kameda,Tatsuya and James,H.Davis,1990,“The Function of the Reference Point in Individual and Group Risk Decision Making”,Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,Vol. 46,pp. 55-76.

    (49)Keay,A. and Zhang,H.,2008,“Incomplete Contracts,Contingent Fiduciaries and a Director’s Duty to Creditors”,Melbourne University Law Review,The University of Melbourne.

    (50)Ketchen,D. J. and Palmer,T. B.,1999.“Strategic Responses to Poor Organizational Performance: A Test of Competing Perspectives”,Journal of Management,Vol. 21,pp. 683-706.

    (51)Kim,K. H. and Tsai,W.,2012,“Social Comparison among Competing Firms”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol. 2(33),pp. 115-136.

    (52)Kriesberg,S. M.,1976,“Decision Making Models and The Control of Corporate Crime”,Yule Law Journal,Vol. 85(8),pp. 1091-1129.

    (53)Labianca,G.and Fairbank J. F.,2005,“Inter-organizational Monitoring: Process,Choices,and Consequences”,Advances in Strategic Management,Vol. 22,pp. 117-150.

    (54)Labianca,G.,Fairbank,J. F.,Andrevski,G. and Parzen,M.,2009,“Striving toward the Future: Aspiration-Performance Discrepancies and Planned Organizational Change”,Strategic Organization,Vol. 7(4),pp. 433-466.

    (55)Lant,T. K.,1992,“Aspiration Level Adaptation: An Empirical Exploration”,Management Science,Vol. 38,pp. 623-644.

    (56)Larson,J. R.,1989,“The Dynamic Interplay between Employees' Feedback-Seeking Strategies and Supervisors' Delivery of Performance Feedback”,Academy of Management Review,Vol. 14(3),pp. 408-422.

    (57)Lehner,M. L.,2000,“Shifts of Reference Points for Framing of Strategic Decisions and Changing Risk-Return Associations”,Management Science,Vol. 46,pp. 63-76.

    (58)Levinthal,D. and March,J. G.,1981,“A Model of Adaptive Organizational Search”,Journal of Economy Behavior and Organization,Vol. 2,pp. 307-333.

    (59)Lin,C. H. and Tsai,C.,2006,“Comparisons and Advertising: The Route from Comparisons to Effective Advertising”,Journal of Business and Psychology,Vol. 21(1),pp. 23-44.

    (60)Mac Lean,T.,2008,“Framing and Organizational Misconduct: A Symbolic Interaction is Study”,Journal of Business Ethics,Vol. 78,pp. 3-16.

    (61)Maddala,G.S.,1983,Limited-dependent and Qualitative Variables in Economics,Cambridge University Press.

    (62)March,J. G. and Shapira Z.,1987,“Managerial Perspectives on Risk and Risk Taking”,Management Science,Vol. 33(11),pp. 1404-1418.

    (63)March,J. G.,1988,“Variable Risk Preferences and Adaptive Aspirations”,Journal of Economy Behavior and Organization,Vol. 2,pp. 9-24.

    (64)March,J. G. and Shapira Z.,1992,“Variable Risk Preferences and the Focus of Attention”,Psychological Review,Vol. 99(1),pp. 172-183.

    (65)March,J. and H. A. Simon,1958,Organizations,John Wiley,New York.

    (66)March J. G.,1991,“Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning”,Organization Science,Vol. 2(1),pp. 71-87.

    (67)Markus,H. and Nurius,P.,1986,“Possible Selves”,American Psychologist,Vol. 41,pp. 954-69.

    (68)Martins,L. L.,2005,“A Model of the Effects of Reputational Rankings on Organizational Change”,Organization Science,Vol. 16,pp.701-20.

    (69)Massini,S.,Lewin,A. Y. and Greve,H. R.,2005,“Innovators and Imitators: Organizational Reference Groups and Adoption of Organizational Routines”,Research Policy,Vol. 34,pp. 1550-1569.

    (70)Merton,Robert K.,1968,Social Theory and Social Structure,Glencoe,Free Press.

    (71)Mezias,J. M.,2002,“Identifying Liabilities of Foreignness and Strategies to Minimize their Effects: The Case of Labor Lawsuit Judgments in the United States”,Strategic Management Journal,Vol. 23,pp. 229-244.

    (72)Mezias,S. J.,Chen,Y. R. and Murphy,P.,2002,“Adaptive Aspirations in an American Financial Services Organization: A Field Study”,Management Science,Vol. 48,pp. 1285-1300.

    (73)Mishina,Y.,Dykes,B. J.,Block,E. S. and Pollock,T. G.,2010,“Why ‘Good’ Firms Do Bad Things: The Effects of High Aspirations,High Expectations,and Prominence on the Incidences of Corporate Illegality”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol. 53(4),pp. 701-722.

    (74)Moliterno,Thomas P. and Christine M. Beckman,2009,“Who’s in First? Social Aspirations and Organizational Change”,Working Paper.

    (75)Moran P,Ghoshal S.,1999,“Markets,Firms,and the Process of Economic Development”,Academy of Management Review,Vol. 24(3),pp. 390-412.

    (76)Oliver,C. and Holzinger,I.,2008,“The Effectiveness of Strategic Political Management: A Dynamic Capabilities Framework”,Academy of Management Review,Vol. 33(2),pp. 496-520.

    (77)Palmer T. B. and Wiseman,R.M.,1999,“Decoupling Risk Taking from Income Stream Uncertainty: A Holistic Model of Risk”,Strategic Management,Vol. 20,pp. 1037-1062.

    (78)Pfeffer,J. and Salancik,G. R.,1978,The External Control of Organizations: A Resource Dependence Perspective,Prentice-Hall,New York.

    (79)Porter M. E.,1980,Competitive Strategy,Simon and Schuster US.

    (80)Rudy,B. C. and Johnson,A. F.,2013,“Performance,Aspirations,and Market versus Nonmarket Investment”,Journal of Management,Vol. 10,pp.1-24

    (81)Ruvulo,A. P. and Markus,H. R.,1992,“Possible Selves and Performance: The Power of Relevant Self-Imagery”,Social Cognition,Vol. 10,pp. 95-124.

    (82)Schneider,Sandra L.,1992,“Framing and Conflict: Aspiration Level Contingency,the Status Quo,and Current Theories of Risky Choice”,Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory,and Cognition,Vol. 8(5),pp. 1040.

    (83)Simon,H. A.,1976,Administration Behavior: A Study of Decision-making Process in Administration Organization,New York: Macmillan Publishing.

    (84)Skinner,D. and R. Sloan,2002,“Earnings Surprises,Growth Expectations,and Stock Returns or Don't Let an Earnings Torpedo Sink Your Portfolio”,Review of Accounting Studies,Vol.l7(2-3),pp. 289-312.

    (85)Sobel,R. S.,2008,“Testing Baumol: Institutional Quality and the Productivity of Entrepreneurship”,Journal of Business Venturing,Vol. 23,pp. 641-655.

    (86)Staw,B. M.,Sandelands,L. E. and Dutton,J. E.,1981,“Threat-Rigidity Effects in Organizational Behavior: A Multilevel Analysis”,Administrative Science Quarterly,Vol. 26,pp. 501-524.

    (87)Suchman,M. C. 1995,“Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches”,Academic Management Review,Vol. 20(3),pp. 571-610.

    (88)Tang,Zhi and Clyde Hull,2012,“An Investigation of Entrepreneurial Orientation,Perceived Environmental Hostility and Strategy Application among Chinese SMEs”,Journal of Small Business Management,Vol. 50(1),pp. 132-158.

    (89)Tesser,A.,Millar,M. and Moore,J.,1988,“Some Affective Consequences of Social Comparison and Reflection Processes: The Pain and Pleasure of Being Close”,Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,Vol. 54(1),pp. 49.

    (90)Vaughan,D.,1999,“The Dark Side of Organizations: Mistake,Misconduct and Disaster”,Annual Review of Sociology,Vol. 5(1),pp. 271-305.

    (91)Weitzel,U.,Urbig,D.,Desai,S.,Sanders,M. and Acs,Z.,2010,“The Good,the Bad and the Talented: Entrepreneurial Talent and Selfish Behavior”,Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,Vol. 76(1),pp. 64-81.

    (92)Wilmot,W. and J. Hocker,2001,Interpersonal Conflict,New York: Mc Graw-Hill,Inc.

    (93)Wiseman,R. M. and Bromiley,P.,1996,“Toward a Model of Risk in Declining Organizations: An Empirical Examination of Risk,Performance and Decline”,Organization Science,Vol. (7),pp. 524-543.

    (94)Wood and Joanne V.,1989,“Theory and Research Concerning So(97)Zucker L.G.,1987,“Normal Change or Risky Business: Institutional Effects on the ‘Hazard’ of Change in Hospital Organizations”,Journal of Management Studies,Vol. 24,pp.671-700.cial Comparisons of Personal Attributes”,Psychological Bulletin,Vol. 106(2),pp. 231-241.

    (95)Yujun Lian,Zhi Su and Yuedong Gu,2011,“Evaluating the Effects of Equity Incentives Using PSM: Evidence from China”,Frontiers of Business Research in China,Vol. 5(2),pp. 266-290.

    (96)Zhang,X. M.,Bartol,K. M.,Smith,K.G.,Pferrer,M. and Khanin,D.,2008,“CEO on the Edge: Earnings Manipulation and Stock-Based Incentive is Alignment”,Academy of Management Journal,Vol. 51(2),pp. 241-258.

    (97)Zucker L. G.,1987,“Normal Change or Risky Business: Institutional Effects on the‘Hazard’of Change in Hospital Organizations”,Journal of Management Studies,Vol. 24,pp. 671-700.

This Article

ISSN:1002-5502

CN: 11-1235/F

Vol , No. 09, Pages 104-124

September 2015

Downloads:2

Share
Article Outline

Abstract

  • 1 Preface
  • 2 Related literature and theoretical hypothesis
  • 3 Data source and sample characteristics
  • 4 Examination result and discussion
  • 5 Robustness test
  • 6 Conclusion
  • Footnote

    References